Score: 9

"LOL"

submission: Creature at the Mill

date: March 27, 2008

You have to be deaf to accuse this of being stolen from One Wing Angel.

Good work again Winter

Score: 10

"Good Job/Response to Bigdoods"

submission: Respite in Eb major

date: March 27, 2008

Generic? CHICK FLICK?? What chickflicks are you watching? This sounds completely seperate. It is very slow and emotional, but that is a style of composition. This does not sound mainstream at all and i think suggesting this isn't played the way he feels is a little rude.

This is a nice piece and it's goin on my iPod, keep up the good work!

Score: 9

"Good work"

submission: Course of Evil || Megaman 2

date: March 27, 2008

This sounds like it could belong in an MMX version of Wily's Stage! Like real actual music, it's great. However you have nearly a minute of emptiness at the end!

Score: 10

"Great success in my opinion."

submission: An Ominous Persona

date: March 27, 2008

Everyone's senses are different, so before i begin, understand that i don't want you to weight my opinions too heavily against your own. Especialy since you've made this yourself, you will catch things in the piece that i won't. But on the other hand, i won't be catching the smaller 'errors' because all of the goodness of this piece just mends it right up and prevents me from realizing the smallest flaws at all.

First of all, the piano is fine, don't fix it. I don't really know why anyone is mentioning it's off-time. I'm not a music expert, though. If it is off time it's just adding to the attitude of this piece. An ominous persona, a person of dark personality and mystery, to me a good piano part like defines the role perfectly. If it's off-time, in my opinion that is not a flaw but an unintended improvement.

Also this is a good quality song. Good sound levels, alot of songs i hear on here are very obnoxious with too much noise and almost screaching. You've got some guitar parts here that are borderline screachy but it's on the awsome side of that border! :)

You should be proud of yourself, this is an excellent display of skill, and i always love guitars and pianos :D It's goin on my iPod!